Expert Opinion or Hidden Narrative: How Pro-Russian Narratives Penetrate Ukrainian Information Space
Analysts highlight mechanisms through which pro-Russian narratives can spread in Ukrainian and European information spaces under the guise of expert assessments, even from individuals with anti-Putin reputations.
🧠AI AnalysisPhoto: RBC-Ukraine
Key points
- Trust in experts can replace verification of information.
- Pro-Russian narratives can penetrate under the guise of expert opinion.
- Using Kremlin phrasing with anti-Putin conclusions is dangerous.
- Importance of critical thinking and fact-checking for the audience.
Analyzing Information Risks
The Ukrainian and European information space faces a challenge where trust in speakers with an impeccable anti-Putin reputation or a dissident past can supersede a thorough verification of their statements. Journalist and military-political analyst Mykola Yakovenko, in his column for RBC-Ukraine, analyzes how this mechanism allows pro-Russian narratives to penetrate under the guise of expert opinion.
An example of such a situation was a November broadcast on the Freedom TV channel, where conflictologist Arif Yunusov, head of the conflictology department at the Institute of Peace and Democracy of Azerbaijan, commented on Baku's support for Ukraine. Yunusov described Azerbaijan's aid, which includes 159 humanitarian cargoes, generators, transformers, and over $40 million by mid-2024, as "not that significant," contradicting facts presented in the same broadcast.
Unconscious Dissemination of Kremlin Narratives
According to Yakovenko, Yunusov, with thirty years of experience studying Baku's foreign policy, could not have made such false statements out of ignorance. This indicates the use of expert status to disseminate a particular narrative, which goes unchecked due to trust in the speaker.
Furthermore, Yunusov used phrasing in his comments that aligned with Kremlin narratives. For instance, he claimed that for Putin, "it is not a tsar's business to communicate with his boyars," explaining the lack of apology for the downed Azerbaijani airliner. He also stated that "the entire eastern part of Ukraine was already his" before the war, and Putin "struck his own people," reflecting a world map depicted by the Kremlin. These formulations, expressed by an individual with a political prisoner's biography and a reputation as a Kremlin critic, can be perceived as common sense rather than propaganda.
The analyst emphasizes that such an optic, where the world is described in Putin's words but with anti-Putin conclusions, is dangerous. It allows hidden pro-Russian ideas to penetrate public consciousness, as the audience's filter is tuned to enemies, not to those they trust.
Source RBC-Ukraine — rbc.ua/ukr/news/chomu-prorosiyski-tezi-naynebezpechnishe-1795173013… ↗
Read next
🎓EducationDrohobych College and 'Galician Cross' Organization Sign Cooperation Agreement
Drohobych Mechanical and Technological Vocational College has signed a memorandum with a veteran organization to strengthen national-patriotic education for students.
🛡️SecurityTrump administration pushes for Ukraine-Russia peace deal by January
The Trump administration is accelerating efforts to broker a peace agreement before the new US Congress takes office.
EU allocates €1 billion for Ukraine's defense: strengthening military and diplomatic positions
EU countries have agreed to allocate 1 billion euros through the European Peace Facility to procure critical military equipment for Ukraine.
🇺🇦UkraineRussian Foreign Ministry Reacts to Potential Role of Kaja Kallas in Future Negotiations
The Russian Foreign Ministry has criticized the potential involvement of Kaja Kallas in future peace talks, labeling her position as destructive.
France calls for UN Security Council meeting following Russian attack on Ukraine
French Foreign Minister Jean-Noël Barrot has requested an emergency UN Security Council meeting after a massive Russian strike caused civilian casualties and damaged fore…
Light discipline in the Kyiv region: new restrictions for businesses and residents
The Brovary community is implementing a nighttime light blackout regime to improve safety and protect critical infrastructure.